Logo design was rejected, what can I correct?

Hello,

I need your support since my work in any ways will not be accepted by the review team and I do not agree with the comments of rejection… Perhaps I understand something wrong, so I ask you for help.

I received two mails with comments:

Reason: You need to make sure all elements are included in the art board. Also, the eyeball concept is a little week .Think about how you can strengthen this concept up, perhaps removing any unnecessary lines and refining the shapes so it’s a stronger, more clear logo mark.

and the second one:

Reason: This is a resubmission of a previously rejected submission. Resubmitting without making the required changes or any improvements is not considered acceptable use of the Envato marketplaces and repeated attempts may result in a temporary or permanent suspension of authorship. If this item was previously soft-rejected, please resubmit your updated files by updating the item directly. If this item was previously hard-rejected, it must be changed as required in the initial review or significantly improved such that it qualifies as a new item.

Item look like this:

And according to the first comment I’ve created screen of eyeball screen where you can see that there are only required nodes and nothing else!

Besides, I checked whether the import from EPS stays in designboard and everything is and it is where it should be.

What should I do if do not agree with the reviewer comments? Lose job and the time which I spent on it? Run the risk to disable an account? Or change the shape of the logo, only to be approved?

Thank you and have a nice day!

No, you dont loose anything, but learn. Look, in my opinion is that put this logo down for a while. Go for an another one, and later you can take this back on your desktop. This is not a kind of job with deadlines here, no boss, no client. Only you. Take an advantage on this possibility.

dekurvajo said
No, you dont loose anything, but learn. Look, in my opinion is that put this logo down for a while. Go for an another one, and later you can take this back on your desktop. This is not a kind of job with deadlines here, no boss, no client. Only you. Take an advantage on this possibility.

Yes, i know and I’m doing it in this way. But this not a point of my problem, please look: - Still I’m receiving comments with wich I cannot agree. Eyeball concept is simple as it can be (there are no unecessary curves and nodes) and everything is within design board (at least in Corel Draw program).

And the question is what to do in this situation, because this it turning around… it seems that I have to forget about this job, work with the another ones and keep fingers crossed that this situation is not repeated.

No… do not “keep your fingers crossed” its more difficult to work in that way.

What i mean with this sentence? Because im not offensive just want you to realize, there will be a lot of rejection always. And im pretty sure this logo would be accepted if you work a lot on it. But Does it worth to make yourself more frustrated? I dont think so. Be honest with yourself is this the best what you can do, or you can make something much more unique? Im pretty sure you can. And you know what? I think the reviewer also think about in this way, because maybe recognized your real skills. And he was strict with you, because he want you to create something much better. Something which might fits more to yourself. Keep walking…

dekurvajo said
No… do not “keep your fingers crossed” its more difficult to work in that way. What i mean with this sentence? Because im not offensive just want you to realize, there will be a lot of rejection always. And im pretty sure this logo would be accepted if you work a lot on it. But Does it worth to make yourself more frustrated? I dont think so. Be honest with yourself is this the best what you can do, or you can make something much more unique? Im pretty sure you can. And you know what? I think the reviewer also think about in this way, because maybe recognized your real skills. And he was strict with you, because he want you to create something much better. Something which might fits more to yourself. Keep walking…

Relax, I am not frustrated (although my posts would look like but believe that it is not) and definitely do not have negative feelings towards anyone.

I can not figure why I get so many comments, maybe I do not adapt projects to the existing rules… But the problem is that sometimes I have to send model two times to review team to receive a fair description of what should be improved.

Every day I work in a company in which the principle is the same, the document must go through a review and approval process but it is striking what to change when there is nothing do to.

Nevertheless, thank you for your help (and of course for what you said), I also know that I can afford more, but I made this sign at very low cost, and I thought that the same will get it on the page, unfortunately…