Hello Friends, recently I had submitted glass menus but it got rejected first time because the category was not right, then I submitted that again in the category mentioned by reviewer but again it got rejected saying that it does not meet current graphic requirements . Please have a look at my menu item & let me know what all changes I need to do to make it get approved.
For me whenever any of my item get’s rejected it’s the same reviewer always (Do not want to disclose the name). I don’t know what he/she is expecting. Actually I think he/she compares submitted items with the current item which he/she should not do actually. If according to him/her that particular submission looks good then he/she should approve it rather than comparing it with other items in the GR library.Here’s my submitted item: http://www.hostingpics.net/viewer.php?id=300332GlassMenus.jpg
I would work on the preview image. Use a more neat, professional font for the heading and add a soft texture to the background.
Also I would focus on one use for the file, rather then two.
It looks great, but what kind of a response do the buttons give when mouse hover, down and pressed…. I think it would be much better to use it as trasure under illustrations rather than web buttons.. but as for buttons this is really a creative idea.. but not sure how much is it usable.. Im not an expert to comment like this.. this is my frank idea on how I feel it.. and when you preview it use a textured back ground and clean fonts to highlight your work….... those bricks are brilliant….. and one thing.. I think it’s better to reduce the perspectiveness when using as the buttons.. because it would be hard to see the button caption when they are in this perspective and there will be a problem in arranging the perspective views of the other items on the web page where these buttons lie…....