(Locked) Reviewers need to think twice before rejecting themes

RubenBristian said
You need a second opinion? Ask the reviewer who approved the PSD theme I still don’t understand why you don’t recognize your mistake and approve the file..

He didn’t make a mistake, he said it was a spacing issue on one of the pages. I still don’t understand why you don’t recognize your mistake, fix it, and resubmit it.

LandonWilson said

RubenBristian said
You need a second opinion? Ask the reviewer who approved the PSD theme I still don’t understand why you don’t recognize your mistake and approve the file..

He didn’t make a mistake, he said it was a spacing issue on one of the pages. I still don’t understand why you don’t recognize your mistake, fix it, and resubmit it.

This sounds like it has become a stubborn pride issue more than anything at this point. The fallacy in the argument is that you assume that because a PSD was approved it must be perfect – that doesn’t mean another reviewer won’t spot something that could be improved (or even that the coded version might not be 100% accurate to the PSD )

Ruben, sometimes the best thing that can happen is a soft rejection. It means that you’re on the cusp of being approved, and the reviewer has found a minor correction that should be made. In the end, this will help you sell more files. It’s a good thing! Try to relax and take a positive attitude toward this type of constructive feedback

Great responses from Jarel and Ivor, btw, you guys are very composed and have a lot of patience. Much respect.

And well said, Koev.

Ok guys, i give up! You’re right, it’s a pride issue and i won’t stand up anymore.. I’ll patiently wait for a wise decision from the reviewer’s part.

Sorry for all the trouble i’ve made with this thread. You can lock it now.

Well, it sounds like, given that this was a soft rejection and not a hard rejection, it’ll be approved just as soon as you make those specific changes. I expect we’ll see the file up soon

Locked on request.