Strange rejection

I upload just the new preview of my already accepted logo and I received this rejection message.

“The wifi rays or beams need more refinement. You need to consider the shaping of these to make them tessellate with each other and be shaped more uniformly.”

I think he’s right. But don’t know for sure until I see the design

Well detailed rejection!

lol he was taking out mistakes from a design which is already accepted. I just expanded the preview of that.

Wonder to get same level of detail on rejection emails!

Here is the accepted file

Here is the rejected preview

To maintain logic with wave, the waves need to be bent parallel to the surface (locator head); needs radius+center point adjustment for all the beams. It is visible at first sight. But the reviewer might caught it just now, the wave will be better if improved.

mudi said
I upload just the new preview of my already accepted logo and I received this rejection message.

“The wifi rays or beams need more refinement. You need to consider the shaping of these to make them tessellate with each other and be shaped more uniformly.”

It’s shameful…. We understand your frustration as the same happened with us not long ago, with an AE project. Perhaps it happens because they don’t have enough time to review all the items they get, and they’re in such a hurry that they don’t pay attention to the fact a submission is simpy a re-editing (therefore: already reviewed and accepted) or a new item. Sometimes we get the impression that they easily reject items to go faster and get more work done…....

expressodesign said

mudi said
I upload just the new preview of my already accepted logo and I received this rejection message.

“The wifi rays or beams need more refinement. You need to consider the shaping of these to make them tessellate with each other and be shaped more uniformly.”

It’s shameful…. We understand your frustration as the same happened with us not long ago, with an AE project. Perhaps it happens because they don’t have enough time to review all the items they get, and they’re in such a hurry that they don’t pay attention to the fact a submission is simpy a re-editing (therefore: already reviewed and accepted) or a new item. Sometimes we get the impression that they easily reject items to go faster and get more work done…....

This happened to me second time. and I wrote to reviewer that its preview update. So why this happened lol.

VF said
To maintain logic with wave, the waves need to be bent parallel to the surface (locator head); needs radius+center point adjustment for all the beams. It is visible at first sight. But the reviewer might caught it just now, the wave will be better if improved.

In other words the reviewer probably wants you to create a logo instead of stacking two shapes / icons on top of each other. Reviewers are doing a much needed crackdown on quality throughout all marketplaces.